top of page

AEW Continental Classic | Roundtable

9 minutes ago
15 min read

Welcome to the #PWMRoundtable, a discussion where PWM contributors weigh in on their views, this week on the 2026 iteration of the Continental Classic. These conversations will range from the serious to the silly and from the latest controversy to questions from deep in wrestling history. Anything pro-wrestling related is fair game, the only limitations being that the debate remain friendly and that we bring some insight that makes it worth your time as a reader


This week’s contributors are Sergei and Sam B. This week our moderator organizing it all (as well as writing up a lot of the contributions) is Sam Preston.


 A page of links to prior installments may be found here: #Roundtable


We'd love for this and any and all of our content to be the beginning of a conversation with our readers. To interact with any and all of our contributors please accept our invitation to join the Pro Wrestling Musings Community Discord.


Continental Classic 2026 Roundtable


moderated by Sam Preston


For those familiar with PWMusings, you will be more than aware that one of our favourite times of the year is the period that the Continental Classic occurs. It combines many of our beloved tropes: great wrestling, characters we are invested in, matches with meaning and purpose, story arcs, and making us feel rewarded for caring. The standard of stories, tournaments, and even winners over the first three years have been of high quality, and at a time when AEW seems to be firing on multiple cylinders, the anticipation for this year might be at an all-time high. 


For this Roundtable, we intend to look at several questions. Should Jon Moxley retain the Continental Championship? If not, who would be our preferred winner? Who would be our choice for a breakout performance? Should there be a Women’s version? Should we expand into the Tag Team or Trios Division, and make it an entire month of Classics? And if we get time, we will discuss whether we think the leagues should be renamed?



Should Jon Moxley Retain the Continental Championship?



Sam Preston: No.


I appreciate that I am likely to be an outlier on this, but not only do I think Jon Moxley should not retain the title, I’d go so far as to say I’ve not enjoyed his title reign at all. At the time, it seemed nonsensical to have him reach the semifinals considering the storyline seemed to be his gradual fall after losing the AEW World Title, let alone to win the Continental Championship outright. His speech after winning the tournament was cited as turning him from a full heel into a burgeoning anti-hero, as it demonstrated he was still a tremendous wrestler and fighter, something I found incredulous considering he had showed no remorse for his heelish actions over the previous 16 months, and suddenly he was just forgiven?


The decision to have him as Continental Champion, has grown to seemingly be an excuse to have him winning multiple matches while keeping him out of the main title scene (except for when the lead in to AEW All In seemed to focus more on him than Will Ospreay, and then he got to challenge Ospreay at AEW All Out, in another exhausting Death Riders main event debacle). But this for me has been a detriment, as it’s meant a full year of matches where I sit there expecting every one of his matches to be a “Lol, Moxley Wins” affair, usually with his opponent looking like an idiot by relying on the same moves every time while Moxley gets to look a genius for doing something different each time. In twenty-nine eliminators, title defences, or Continental Cup bollocks, I’ve found myself awaiting the inevitable Moxley victory, with little to no expectation that the opponent has any chance of winning.


It’s been especially painful seeing wrestlers who could have truly benefitted from being Continental Champion – such as Josh Alexander, Konosuke Takeshita, Kyle O’Reilly, Bandido, Jay White, Claudio Castagnoli, Mike Bailey, even Will Ospreay at AEW Dynasty – just used to put over Moxley when really, this felt like the year that Moxley should have helped elevate others instead. Having sat through another Moxley title reign, I feel I need a break from him as champion – if he must be a champion, put him in a Tag Team, Trios, or even ROH reign. Anywhere which would benefit more from his involvement than a stagnated Continental Division.


Sergei: Among the fanbase as a whole, Sam P is indeed an outlier – as can be heard from the cheers whenever Moxley speaks or wrestles – but among Pro Wrestling Musings contributors I feel VERY outnumbered and attacked in continuing to love Jon Moxley. Peter said much the same as Sam P does above about the Ace’s Continental reign in Moxley’s GOAT 100 installment. 


HOWEVER, the question at hand is whether Moxley should retain in the C2, and that is NOT necessarily a referendum on whether his reign has been worthwhile… (imo, it has!) because none of the previous C2 tournament winners has gone on to win the C2 the following year, and I say there’s NO reason to start now!


Not because Moxley as Continental Champion hasn't been great or couldn't continue to be great, (I agree with Sam B below and not Sam P on that point)... But because I feel like winning in consecutive years would undersell the insane difficulty and precariousness of the tournament itself. And that is one of the aspects that gives the Continental title its unique character that makes it more than just another gold prop.


To me, the more interesting question is: should Moxley make it to the finals? After all, every reigning champion going into the C2 has. Of course, that has only meant Okada twice, so far. On the other hand, Moxley did also make the finals in the C3, the new summer knockout tournament.


On the one hand, having the new Continental champion defeat the old in the finals would be legitimizing, and eliminating Moxley early could be seen as a disrespect to the Ace of AEW. On the other, having him eliminated early, not even able to reach the semis, would set the precedent that anything can happen in the Continental Classic – that the level of competition is SO high that nobody is guaranteed anything. In my opinion, that would be the move.


(On the other hand, I wrote all of the above before the selection special on Monday Night. Either Jay or Hangman or both are almost bound to make the finals for the Blue League, and one (or even both) should definitely face Moxley in the semis and/or finals, so if I'm right about that, that puts the kibosh on the idea of eliminating him in the round robin stage.)


Sam B: Yes.


I’m not just being a contrarian here.


I think a lot of arguments around taking the title off of Mox revolve around the idea that other wrestlers could use the belt but to be blunt, even if they were given it, none of them are as good as Jon Moxley or as compelling to watch as him. There are just so many things that Moxley does better and with more consistency than anyone else in the company. Mic work, he has proven year after year that while some can reach his level, no one else remains on it consistently. He has for years been both the Ace and the workhorse of the company, among those wrestlers putting on the most matches every year. Sure, there are others you could perhaps claim are better at the mechanics of wrestling and AEW is certainly the domain of the super workers. However, to that I would say that no one so wholly inhabits their character and draws people into everything they do more than Mox. This point was driven home to me when I saw Mox live in the flesh – every sinew of his body was tensed like he was a coiled spring ready to come unglued and enact brutal violence on his opponent. That night, I saw Kenny Omega, Will Ospreay, Kazuchika Okada, Kyle Fletcher, Konosuke Takeshita, Mercedes Mone and Toni Storm do all sorts of amazing things in the ring, and yet my enduring memory from that night is how a caged Mox stalked his way to the ring.


I have at times found Jon Moxley’s run as Continental Champion maddening for many of the reasons outlined by others, primarily the schizophrenic characterisation he has displayed, committing to neither face nor heel. However, he has now been placed firmly in the position I believe he is most compelling in, a scrappy, gritty, blue-collar folk-hero face of the people. The version of him that shouldered AEW through the pandemic and 2022’s Phil Brooks-induced issues. This will remove the issue of character consistency and place him in a position that AEW crowds have flocked to see him in over many years and have only gotten more into as 2026 has gone onwards. The Continental Title creates a division around him and very few other performers have the ability to make the title mean something the way Mox has. Like it or not, Jon Moxley remains the Ace of this company, the most consistent high-level performer in its history, and I see no reason he should be stripped of the title that keeps him in the spotlight.




If Not Moxley, Who Would You Like To See As Champion?



Sam Preston: Despite my thoughts above about Moxley, deep down, there is an element of it that I understand, and that’s where having a former AEW World Champion be successful in another division helps elevate the importance of it. A former World Champion deciding that a title is worth their attention helps with making that title seem to matter, as exemplified by instances such as Darby Allin with the recent TNT Title, Kenny Omega with the International Championship and Trios Championship, Adam Page also with the Trios Championship, Moxley with the International Title, Swerve Strickland with the Trios Championship as well, MJF with the International Title. Ironically, the Continental Championship has only had Moxley focus on it, which gives an opportunity for others to possibly take up this task. But we also have to take into account, what are the intentions for the next Continental Champion? Will it be someone similar to Kazuchika Okada and Jon Moxley, who held the title for over 300 days? Or more akin to an Eddie Kingston, a short term fighting champion who will lose it within 3-6 months?


If the latter, a short term champion, there are two individuals who come to mind immediately for myself, one a former AEW World Champion, and the other relatively new to the company. The first would be ‘Hangman’ Adam Page, who in a previous article I argued would suit the Continental Championship due to his honourable demeanour and need to rediscover himself after losing the right to challenge for the AEW World Title. While currently battling for the AEW Trios Championship, the challenge of the Continental Classic is something he’s yet to battle, and even if he only holds the title for several months as part of a gradual transition to a longer term option, it would help his overall arc of proving to himself he’s still championship material. The second is Ilja Dragunov, who could easily have a Darby Allin-esque title reign where he faces all challengers for a month or two nonstop, then finally gets vanquished by someone taking advantage.


If however, Tony Khan sticks to the same standard of the last two champions, then I’m going with what may seem a surprising choice, in Jay White. With his recent big heel turn and rebranding of the Bang Bang Gang into The Cut, he’s in need of several major  victories to help legitimise White as a major threat. There is already the Anarchy In The Arena match for AEW Full Gear, but what he needs more than anything is several victories as a singles competitor, and what could be better than the Continental Classic? In the 2023 edition, he earned 12 points with 4 wins and a single loss to future World Champion Swerve Strickland, before succumbing to Moxley in the Semi-Final Triple Threat (also featuring Swerve). White as a heel is often a more defensive, intelligent wrestler, taking advantage of injuries, utilising reverses and outsmarting his opponent, which could put an interesting wrinkle upon the rules of the Continental Title. Having had more fails than achievements during his AEW career, including still having the stink of AEW Full Gear 2023 levied against him, this could help his recovery.


Sergei: This is an incredibly strong field making this a tough, tough question. Hardly anybody among these dozen is obviously there to eat pins. Almost any of them could be used that way, but practically all of them would be credible champions as well.


So the tie-breaker for me is – if Hangman Adam Page is Continental Champion, it will KILL Swerve that he can't interfere in his championship defenses, and that's hilarious to me.


Sam B: DUH… Hangman Adam Page


Honestly, this is the same answer I would give for ‘who is the next wrestler that should win x title’ for just about any title in AEW at the moment.


It isn’t just because he manages to make every title reign and feud meaningful and character-driven in a way no other wrestler does. It isn’t just because accumulating a series of title reigns that aren’t the World Championship would fit his current storyline so well. It isn’t just because I know he would have incredible matches and I want to see him prove he is as good as any of the super workers when it comes to in-ring performance. It isn’t just because I want to see him mix it up in singles action with more midcast opponents he really hasn’t touched yet. It isn’t just because he would look damn good with that title around his waist. It isn’t just because it would force Swerve to somehow try and have a straight singles match with him if he wanted to antagonise Hangman more. It isn’t just because he is my favourite wrestler.


I guess it is because of all of those reasons!




Would You Want To See A Women’s Version?



Sam Preston: Yes.


Sorry, you need more? Okay, how about a Women’s Division currently at its best with champions and active past champions such as Mercedes Mone, Toni Storm, Kris Statlander, Jamie Hayter, Queen Aminata, Athena, and a ridiculous amount more? What about the fact that whenever the women are given opportunities, they put together some of the best matches in the company? Blood ‘n’ Guts (literally any of them), Hollywood Ending, the Thunder Rosa / Britt Baker Unsanctioned match, the Statlander-Nightingale Chicago Street Fight, when the women get time, they show up and impress. 


If they did proceed with a Women’s Continental Classic, rather than creating another title, I think they should have the TBS Championship instead, focusing on the mid to lower section of the Women’s Division. With a TBS Champion automatically included, this allows individuals like Queen Aminata, Dani Luna, Persephone, Maya World, Harley Cameron, the Sisters of Sin, etc, to get more featured time and extra storylines. If you even wanted to have a set-up similar to the first Continental Classic, you could also have the CMLL Women’s Champion and a ROH Champion (I’d suggest the ROH Pure Title myself) feature to make it a bigger event.


Sergei: Yes, but not like that!


There are titles that I don’t feel have a purpose besides giving somebody a prop to hold and something to fight over, but imho, that’s the National and International Championships, and not the TBS championship. The TBS and TNT championships have a role in their respective divisions, and the Continental championship has a different role in the men’s division, and they don’t overlap. The workhorse TV championship and the no-outside-interference special title are both valid purposes for a title and division and should separately co-exist within a division.


So if not taking over the TBS title name, what should the Women’s version of a Continental title be called? Consider the similar division that has special match rules in ROH: the Pure division. The Champions among the men and the women in Pure-style matches are just Men’s Pure Champion and Women’s Pure Champion, and I think that should work the same for the Continental Championships.


So, the question becomes “When?” When should we do the Women’s Continental Championship? I’ll say right away that doing it at the same time or one-after-the-other with the Men’s C2 sounds like a terrible idea! But as for what I would do… my idea is a little bit of a spoiler for Sam P’s suggestion for timing C2s for different divisions in the next section, so: see below in the “Continental Tag Team” question…




Should There Be A Tag Team / Trios Championship?


Sam Preston: Again, yes.


A major ethos of AEW has been making tag team wrestling just as important as singles wrestling. The Tag Team division currently has four of the best tag teams in history, in the Young Bucks, FTR, New Level, and Motor City Machine Guns, not taking into account talented former champions such as Brodido, Cage & Cope, future possibles such as Davis and Doyle, Rascalz, etc. Then you extend into the Trios division, with New Level & Swerve, Don Callis Family, Death Riders, The Demand, etc, a roll call of tremendous teams that the audience loves. Two of the current best stories are the series of matches between Swerve & New Level against Hangman and Brodio, as well as the Best-of-Five series between FTR and Motor City Machine Guns. Historically, audiences have loved the wars between Young Bucks & Lucha Brothers, the Elite and Death Triangle, FTR and the Briscoe Brothers. 


The original intention of the Continental Classic was an American version of the much beloved G1 Climax tournament popularised in NJPW, but unbeknownst to some, there was another tournament before it that popularised the Round Robin tournament just as much. Since 1977, All Japan Pro Wrestling would run the Real World Tag League, featuring anything up to 13 tag teams in a Round Robin tournament, and was instrumental in the gradual growth of the beloved AJPW Four Pillars, including several early classics in their career. At a time when tag team and trios division are getting major focus, it would be nonsensical to not have a tournament dedicated. 


To avoid having four tournaments possibly going on at once, my recommendation would be to have the Men’s Tag Team, Women’s Tag Team, and Trios Tournaments alternate every 3 years, and have the current champions feature in the tournament. For this year, if possible, I’d kick off with the Women’s Tag Team, with the Brawling Birds entering as defending champions.


Sergei: First off, hell no.


My perspective on the Continental Championship is that it is NOT fundamentally a round-robin championship. The Continental title is defended in the round-robin C2 just once a year (and based on Sam P’s thoughts above, would it be alternating years?) But the title remains and continues to be defended year round and (unlike the AEW National and International titles!) has a unique identity all that time. And what defines that unique identity is: no seconds at ringside. The unique selling point of the Continental division is a competitor being forced into a situation where they have nothing to rely on but themself.


Which is… y’know… the exact opposite of what tag-team and trios wrestling are about. If you want to bring in AEW’s version of AJPW’s World’s Strongest Tag Determination League? I’m all for it! But that tournament never had its own special title as the prize, and neither should AEW’s version. The Continental title wouldn’t work itself, except that the title is special and different. A C2 winner might say: “I went through ALL THAT for a title… and now any schlub could take it from me by winning just ONE match?” Except for the fact that the Continental title is specifically proof that you have the grit and ability to win something that gang tactics couldn't have helped you with, PLUS a prize that now that you have it, also can’t be taken from you with gang tactics.


So… to return to the question of when? If they were to expand to TWO (not five) Continental divisions – Men's and Women's – as I propose, when should they do their respective C2s? Let me start by saying that I hate, hate, HATE the idea of alternating years (not enough round-robin goodness!) but I’ll admit doing them both in the Most Wonderful Time of the Year would be a bit too much of a good thing. Until recently, I would’ve simply said: Men’s Winter, Women’s Summer, easy! But this past summer they added the C3 (the Continental Challenge Cup) to the Continental calendar in the summer each year. But that works, too!


I say just do one per season: Men’s C2 in the winter, Women’s C2 in the spring, Men’s C3 in the summer and Women’s C3 in the autumn.



Sam B

No, not everyone can have a C2. You only need to look at the snoozefest that is World Tag League in NJPW to see how a good concept can quickly become redundant when it is repeated too often each year. While AEW does probably have a sufficient tag division to support it, the C2 is special because it only happens once a year. If they wanted to perhaps once every five years they could turn it over to tag teams, or even better do something different with the tag teams – maybe they could have a giant knockout tournament over the winter Worlds End to Revolution stretch: a 16 or 32 team bracket, bigger than any other tournament – crucially giving the division its own identity and keeping the C2 special.





Should They Rename The Leagues?


Sam Preston: I’ll admit, this was inspired by a tweet I saw recently, where someone suggested renaming the Continental Classic leagues from the Blue League and Gold League, to a Brodie League and PAC League.



The possibility of naming the Leagues after Brodie Lee and PAC, two men who were highly respected and appreciated within the AEW Locker Room, may seem a strange suggestion, but in a company that respects history, it feels right. Between the Owen Hart Foundation Tournaments, the PPV WrestleDream honouring Antonio Inoki, a Butcher Battle Royal, having such an important tournament used to also honour wrestling favourites would be a beautiful touch. Even if we increase the Classics to Women’s, Tag or Trios versions, they can use that to honour individuals such as Rebel and Jay Briscoe. 


Sergei: That’s a really sweet and touching idea from Tom Green (of OFF THE GRID fame) but I come down on the side of No. Blue League and Gold League is very much a case of not-broke, don’t-fix-it, imho.


Sam B: The simple answer is No. Blue and Gold are so utilitarian that they can mean anything but have also now been around long enough that they have an established tradition. However I do like Sam P’s idea of naming them after wrestlers so thought I could take it in a different direction and name them after two of AEW’s retired greats the Sting & Danielson Leagues. If for no other reason than it sets up the possibility of Steve Borden taking out the league named in his Father’s honour or one of the Death Riders taking out Danielson’s side.


©2023 by Pro Wrestling Musings. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page